



greggarious wrote:I think the current Nebular award-winning novel, The Windup Girl by Bacigalupi should stir up a storm. Much as I've loved the author's short stories, and agreed with the accolages they received, his first novel is no masterpiece. Many untied threads, wandering focus, breaks in believability, slightly disappointing ending. Could it have won the Nebula based mainly on theme, which has been one of Paulo's strengths? I wonder what some of the other authors of great '09 novels might say if bold enough to speak freely. A storm of protest and controversy!
But in keeping with the topic, Bacigalupi's writing has indeed inspired my last few contest entries ...
Alex Kane wrote:greggarious wrote:I think the current Nebular award-winning novel, The Windup Girl by Bacigalupi should stir up a storm. Much as I've loved the author's short stories, and agreed with the accolages they received, his first novel is no masterpiece. Many untied threads, wandering focus, breaks in believability, slightly disappointing ending. Could it have won the Nebula based mainly on theme, which has been one of Paulo's strengths? I wonder what some of the other authors of great '09 novels might say if bold enough to speak freely. A storm of protest and controversy!
But in keeping with the topic, Bacigalupi's writing has indeed inspired my last few contest entries ...
That's a pretty big detail. I wouldn't disclose plot things that specific on the WotF site if I were you. Disqualification for something like that would be terrible, especially if the story might have won otherwise. I'd edit your post.
Sam Hidaka wrote:Alex Kane wrote:greggarious wrote:I think the current Nebular award-winning novel, The Windup Girl by Bacigalupi should stir up a storm. Much as I've loved the author's short stories, and agreed with the accolages they received, his first novel is no masterpiece. Many untied threads, wandering focus, breaks in believability, slightly disappointing ending. Could it have won the Nebula based mainly on theme, which has been one of Paulo's strengths? I wonder what some of the other authors of great '09 novels might say if bold enough to speak freely. A storm of protest and controversy!
But in keeping with the topic, Bacigalupi's writing has indeed inspired my last few contest entries ...
That's a pretty big detail. I wouldn't disclose plot things that specific on the WotF site if I were you. Disqualification for something like that would be terrible, especially if the story might have won otherwise. I'd edit your post.
K.D. will have to give you a definitive opinion here. But in my opinion, saying that a story is inspired by Paulo Bacigalupi is not nearly enough to identify the specific story.
When I first started reading slush, Bacigalupi's story, "The People of Sand and Slag" was getting a lot of buzz. So the slush pile was filled with stories with a similar feel -- ugly worlds populated by grim people.
Now that Paulo Bacigalupi won the Nebula, and tied for the Hugo, there will be an onslaught of Bacigalupi-type stories -- in every slush pile, including WotF.
Sam
Alex Kane wrote:I cut out the plot summary in my quote box. He actually said what his story was specifically about in his post above, which I see is still there, and I think that's a lot of info to be making public, and on the contest's own forum, no less.
It's supposed to be judged blindly; they can't do that if they suspect they know who penned a given story.















Michael B wrote:I was just writing a dramatic scene in my current story and this song popped into my head out of nowhere. Fifth Element Diva Dance:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZJB5Rqc1m0Y&feature=related
I love it, I love it. (Okay, the fight scene is pretty atrocious, but the song is amazing.)
P.S. Snow, I liked Escala's "Finding Beauty". I'll have to remember that one!



Is it a weird aspect of human psychology how if you put monumental, soaring music behind scenes of human destruction ... it takes on a sense of ... righteous Destiny?

Michael B wrote:*shudder* I just realized, with the increasing popularity of e-books this sort of thing could actually start to happen.









Brad R. Torgersen wrote:Just how BIG are the objects in our universe?





as the girl recited Christina Georgina Rossetti's poemAnd if thou wilt, remember,
And if thou wilt, forget.









Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest