First Four-Fifty Critique Exchanges

[Brydar]

I beat my deadline by about 5 minutes! It may not be perfect but I got the first 450 of my story out to those listed above via PM. Please let me know if you have any problems reading it. I am anxious to read your 450's folks, you may PM me back or e-mail me; Brydar at Yahoo dot com.

[jMiriah]

Hey, is anyone else interested in a new round of first-450 exchange?
If so, PM me. Thanks!

[elratliff]

Hello all,

This is my first time doing WotF, and I'd like to swap my first 450 with someone(s) for feedback.
PM me if interested. Thanks!

[Dustin Adams]

Ellie,

Received. Will look it over soon!

[Dustin Adams]

.
Anyone willing to review a prelim 450 (460 actually) for my possible Q1?
Am of course happy to exchange, even a non-wotf if that's all you have available.
Or a flash/complete.

[elratliff]

.
Anyone willing to review a prelim 450 (460 actually) for my possible Q1?
Am of course happy to exchange, even a non-wotf if that's all you have available.
Or a flash/complete.

I'll look at it, Dustin, without the exchange. You've got my email. I don't have anything of my own ready at the moment.

[elratliff]

I just looked at my calendar and realized we'll be midway through Q4 next weekend. Anyone up for a round of first-450 critique exchanges the weekend of Aug 15th-16th?

Edit
Just to clarify what I'd meant by "the weekend": Send me your first 450 by 11:59pm PST Friday, and I'll have your feedback done by 11:59pm PST Sunday.

[Galen]

Good thought. I would be keen to collaborate in a 450 critique exchange. Pretty much anytime works for me.

[elratliff]

Galen - I've sent you an email!

[Galen]

Great! I've sent it over just because I was at it, but your timeline is just fine by me.

[Ivy Fairhaven]

Hello!

Is anyone else looking to exchange the first 450 for Q4? If you are, please let me know with a PM.


Thank you!

[elratliff]

I could use another first 450 exchange. PM me if interested! Thanks!

[Dustin Adams]

I'm ready.
You?
Call me!

[glenn84]

Anyone still need to do a last minute exchange?

[Dustin Adams]

No one has posted in this thread since December?
Or is my Internetweb being funky?

Anyway, with 1 month left, my inbox is open. For a swap - or just a read. I'm up for either if you don't have time to read, but want eyes on your start.

[elratliff]

Anyone interested in a first-450 exchange this weekend (Mar. 11-12)? If you send me something by 11:59pm PST Friday, I'll have your feedback done by 11:59pm PST Sunday.

[jficke13]

Anyone else feel a kick in the patoot from the end of last quarter and the awards riding some creativity into the beginning of this quarter?

I'm up for a (very) early first 450 word exchange if there are any takers?

[J'nae Rae]

I'm up to it. I have story originally started for this quarter before I had a dry spell after my Best Friend passed. I ended up cleaning up a submission that was rejected for an anthology for Q2 instead.

So, PM me the file and I'll see about PMing you mine.

[Dustin Adams]

Let's do this!

Send me a PM for a 450 or 1k exchange for Q3.

Let's make finalist!!!

[elratliff]

My Q4 story is nowhere near started yet, but I'll be happy to exchange 450 critiques with anyone this quarter. So PM/email me if you have one ready, and I will send mine as soon as I have something written!

[Dustin Adams]

Do I have someone's 450?
I've got one on my desktop, and I can't find in my e-mail where I received it. Very strange because I'm an e-mail freak...
Anyway, reply here or send a PM if I have yours and haven't replied.
Incidentally, very good anonymity.

ETA: Mystery solved!

I'm planning a trip for the rest of this quarter, but my mailbox will open back up for Q1 on Oct 2nd.

4 in 35!

[elratliff]

Who's up for a first-450 exchange for Q2? Send me a PM if interested.

[RSchibler]

Always up for crits

[Henckel]

Hi there. Anyone up for a 450 swap?

Just email or pm me.

[KD Lightle]

I'm in. Is this still a thing? How do I get in on this?

Something I'm confused on: If we're supposed to be keeping these confidential - no names, no titles, whatever - how does swapping my story bit with Writer X's story bit, and critiquing on each other's work remain confidential? I know that I got Writer X's work, and Writer X knows they got my work... doesn't that reduce the confidentiality? Can someone explain please?

[disgruntledpeony]

Something I'm confused on: If we're supposed to be keeping these confidential - no names, no titles, whatever - how does swapping my story bit with Writer X's story bit, and critiquing on each other's work remain confidential? I know that I got Writer X's work, and Writer X knows they got my work... doesn't that reduce the confidentiality? Can someone explain please?

The people you specifically need confidentiality from are the judges. Anything that might identify your story should be discussed in private confidence (PM or e-mail) with the person/people with whom you trade, in order to prevent disqualification. It is a bit of an honor system in that you're trusting your fellow entrants to keep from publically reveal anything about your work, but they're trusting you to do the same, so it evens out.

[KD Lightle]

The people you specifically need confidentiality from are the judges. Anything that might identify your story should be discussed in private confidence (PM or e-mail) with the person/people with whom you trade, in order to prevent disqualification. It is a bit of an honor system in that you're trusting your fellow entrants to keep from publically reveal anything about your work, but they're trusting you to do the same, so it evens out.

AAAh. Ok. Thank you!

[Corbin Maxwell]

I got a 450 if anyone is up for a quickie.

[Corbin Maxwell]

It kinda feels like I’m being given the silent treatment for some reason. Like I got wished into the cornfield.

[RSchibler]

If I haven’t seen it I’ll read it. I’ve had a lot going on and am not certain who I’ve read for.